By: Sarah Harris

Bites and scratches drawing blood, hearing loss due to excessive noise and staff taking antidepressants to cope is the reality for early childhood sector.

A new ChildForum report concluded that early childhood teaching can be high-risk work with staff suffering the likes of back injuries from handling children, others experiencing mental health problems and some reporting both.

Cambridge early childhood educator Louise Allen, 50, can vouch for that.

She got into early childhood care four years ago and has worked in a number of centres and a kindergarten. But after a “toxic” experience Allen has moved to home-based care.

Allen recalled horrendously noisy environments, being run into by children on bikes, having her broken toe stood on by a child, being hit, scratched and bitten.

One centre had 17 children in a very small room. Once a manager tested the noise and found it was similar to a jet plane.

Back pain is a given. In Allen’s first job she cared for 1 to 2 year olds – which meant a lot of picking them up.

“I had to go to a chiropractor. My back went out every three months and I needed intense treatment on it. I haven’t had any issues since I’ve left.

“The chiropractor at the time said the life of person working with under 2s is seven years. That’s all they should manage.”

Allen explained that working with children can be stressful, but this is exacerbated when you don’t get the support you need. She wanted the sector to open their ears and listen to teachers more.

“If I had known how hard it was going to be and how bad the pay is there’s no way I would have gone into it. It’s not worth it.

“No one believes you, you’re just seen as a sh*t-stirrer. People learn to shut up and put up with it.

“We need a lot more transparency and be able to speak without being afraid of repercussion.”

Almost 50 per cent of teaching staff reported workplace harm last year. Staff aged under 25 were most at risk, with 70 per cent reporting harm of some form.

There are serious health and social ramifications to be considered from the findings, ChildForum chief executive Dr Sarah Alexander said.

“Health and safety risks to staff need to be better managed. Things such as excessive noise levels leading to hearing loss, staff not getting regular breaks and staff being overworked and unsupported should not be happening at any service.

“The cost, financially and emotionally to staff – the majority are women and many with young children of their own – of working in early childhood education, a profession that is also known for its low pay, can be significant.

“The sector is losing skilled teachers so something has to be done to look after staff better to keep these people in the sector,” Dr Alexander said.

Dr Sarah Alexander is a researcher and chief executive of ChildForum, which provides advice and support to early childhood services. Photo / Supplied

The ChildForum Early Childhood National Network researchers surveyed 900 teachers, including 109 in supervisor positions, as part of the 2017 Early Childhood Education Employment Survey.

In an earlier survey at the end of 2014, 29 per cent of teaching staff and supervisors reported a work-related injury, physical or mental health problem. Alexander believed one reason for the increase could be more publicity around the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015.

Cartilage damage and torn ligaments in their wrist due to a fall, extreme stress, sleeplessness, migraines, severe back problems costing thousands in treatments and using alcohol as a coping mechanism were some of the experiences quoted from surveyed staff.

Comments about mental health problems were made almost as often as comments about injuries and physical problems. One employee reported crying often at work and feeling both physically and mentally drained. Another said they felt less like a teacher and more like a cleaner/babysitter and one female teacher went into premature labour owing to stress.

Alexander suggested that it was time to put “the care” back into early childhood education. She wanted to see the sector invest in staff education around injury prevention.

“Caring for those who care for children has to become a priority.

“It can be really difficult for staff and add to the stress of trying to give a proper service to children when they are feeling undervalued, unsupported and unappreciated around health and safety at work.”

The research recommended training from health and safety experts, reducing, removing or controlling hazards and giving staff equipment that will help prevent injury – for example steps for children so staff don’t have to lift them on and off changing tables.

Edusafe occupational therapists Nadia Tu’itahi and Melissa Caskie were shocked at the harm evident in the report. Photo / Supplied

Edusafe occupational therapist Melissa Caskie called the high-level of harm detailed in the report “heartbreaking”. She said it was proof there wasn’t a lot of injury prevention in a sector that was crying out for it.

“There are a lot of physical issues and psychosocial issues. Psychosocial issues are usually a result of not having a cohesive environment to work in.

“There needs to be a lot more investment into staff and looking at injury-prevention, making them safer, more supported and more valued in the workplace.”

See the ChildForum Teacher Injury Report 2018

Source: NZ Herald

Want more of the latest sector news, information, opinion and discussion straight to your inbox? Subscribe to our free weekly newsletters now:


  1. Thanks Sarah Harris for bringing up this issue. I fully agree to the hectic work in the Early childhood sector. I have faced it several times and specially when the leaders are not able to analyse the tough and painful situations that the other staff faces. If while setting the roster and work schedule they could keep the right balance taking into consideration the health of the teachers then it would be countered to a great extend, Again many of us do not open up but just try to quit the job as due to its stress. I am sure the work atmosphere and system would play a great role here. Definitely, there needs to be a lot more investment into staff and looking at injury-prevention, making them safer, more supported and more valued in the workplace to stops the attrition rate in many Early childhood centres.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here